What is the BC Civil Resolution Tribunal and can it help with fence disputes?

The BC Civil Resolution Tribunal (CRT) is Canada's first online dispute resolution tribunal, and yes, it absolutely handles fence disputes between neighbours — it is in fact the primary legal venue for resolving most fence and boundary disputes in British Columbia. The CRT was created under the Civil Resolution Tribunal Act and has been operating since 2016, specifically designed to provide an accessible, affordable, and efficient alternative to the traditional court system for common disputes.

The CRT has explicit jurisdiction over neighbour disputes, which includes fence disagreements of all types: disputes about shared fence costs and maintenance under Part 5 of the BC Property Law Act, fences built over property lines, overheight fences blocking light or views, damage caused during fence installation, refusal to contribute to boundary fence repair or replacement, and disputes about fence style, materials, or placement on shared boundaries. If your fence dispute involves a claim of $5,000 or less, the CRT has exclusive jurisdiction — meaning you must go through the CRT rather than the courts. For fence disputes involving claims between $5,001 and $10,000, the CRT shares jurisdiction with BC Small Claims Court, and either venue is available.

The CRT process is conducted entirely online, which makes it particularly accessible for homeowners who can't take time off work to attend court hearings. The process has four stages. Stage 1: Solution Explorer — before you can file a dispute, you must complete the CRT's online self-help tool at civilresolutionbc.ca. The Solution Explorer asks you questions about your specific situation and provides tailored legal information about your rights, your neighbour's rights, and the applicable laws. Many disputes are resolved at this stage simply because both parties gain a clear understanding of the law. Stage 2: Negotiation — if you file a dispute (application fee: $75), the CRT's online platform allows you and your neighbour to negotiate directly through a messaging system, with access to CRT-provided legal information and negotiation tools. Many disputes settle at this stage without ever reaching a facilitator. Stage 3: Facilitation — if negotiation doesn't resolve the dispute, a CRT facilitator (a trained mediator) works with both parties to try to reach a settlement. The facilitation is conducted online through the CRT platform. Stage 4: Tribunal Decision — if facilitation fails, a CRT tribunal member reviews all the evidence and submissions and issues a binding written decision. The decision fee is $100. Total fees for a fence dispute that goes all the way to a tribunal decision are therefore $175.

The CRT can order a wide range of remedies for fence disputes, including: payment of money (requiring a neighbour to pay their share of fence costs under the Property Law Act), specific performance (ordering a neighbour to remove a fence, modify a fence, allow access for repairs, or contribute to fence replacement), and declarations (establishing the rights and obligations of each party regarding a shared boundary fence). CRT decisions are legally binding and enforceable through BC Provincial Court — meaning if your neighbour ignores a CRT order, you can file the decision with the court and use the court's enforcement mechanisms (including seizure of assets) to compel compliance.

Timelines for CRT fence disputes are significantly faster than the court system. Most disputes are resolved within 60 to 90 days from filing to decision, compared to 6 to 18 months or more in the traditional court system. The online format means there's no travel, no waiting in courtrooms, and no scheduling delays — you participate from your home computer on your own time (within CRT deadlines).

What makes the CRT particularly effective for fence disputes is its expertise. CRT tribunal members regularly handle neighbour disputes and are familiar with the Property Law Act, municipal bylaws, and the common fact patterns that arise in fence conflicts. They understand the practical realities — that a fence dispute between neighbours involves people who have to continue living next to each other, and that solutions need to be workable, not just legally correct.

Evidence you should prepare for a CRT fence dispute includes a property survey or Land Title Office records showing the property boundary, photographs of the fence and the dispute area, copies of any written communications with your neighbour about the fence, the applicable municipal bylaw provisions (fence height limits, setback requirements), receipts or estimates for fence costs (if the dispute involves cost-sharing), and any expert reports (such as a surveyor's report or an arborist's report if trees are involved).

Limitations of the CRT include that it cannot handle disputes involving claims over $10,000 (those go to BC Supreme Court), it does not have jurisdiction over strata common property fences (those are handled through the CRT's separate strata dispute jurisdiction), and it cannot enforce municipal bylaws (only the municipality can do that through bylaw enforcement). If your fence dispute is primarily about a bylaw violation rather than a private property rights issue, your first step should be a complaint to your municipal bylaw enforcement department rather than a CRT application.

The CRT website at civilresolutionbc.ca provides detailed guides on how to file a dispute, what evidence to gather, and what to expect at each stage. It's an excellent resource even if you're not ready to file — the Solution Explorer alone can clarify your legal position and help you have a more productive conversation with your neighbour.

---

Find a Fencing Contractor

Vancouver Fence Builders connects you with experienced contractors through the https://vancouverconstructionnetwork.com:

• Black Birch Contracting ✓
• ConstructX Developments Inc ✓
• Canyon Property Projects ✓